Skip to main content

Mamata duly consulted



The post-mortem of India's failure to sign the Teesta water sharing treaty with Bangladesh during Indian Prime Minister Manmohan Singh's visit has begun.

The pact was all ready to be signed during Manmohan's 30-hour trip to Dhaka that ended on Wednesday. But it fell through at the last moment because of objection from Paschimbanga Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee. New Delhi said Mamata was duly consulted about the pact.

The collapse of the water treaty almost eclipsed the other gains the two countries achieved from the high-profile visit. This is because the Teesta deal was the most coveted trophy Bangladesh had wanted, according to analysts.

Manmohan said Mamata's last-minute opposition to the deal took him by surprise.

“I was told all the technicalities were settled but in the meantime something obviously happened, and Mamataji disagreed with it,” the prime minister told Indian journalists accompanying him aboard a special plane taking him back to New Delhi on Wednesday.

He also provided some details of his steps to finalise the draft of the deal.

"I sent National Security Adviser Shiv Shankar Menon to talk to Mamataji a long time ago. He met her in Kolkata and then he also undertook a mission to Dhaka,” Manmohan said.

“But some other factors came into play, and she (Mamata) said she won't come. It is only then, I realised about disagreement with regard to the Teesta,” he said.

He further said when the Teesta treaty issue had come up before the cabinet committee on political affairs a few days prior to his trip to Dhaka, Railway Minister and Mamata's party colleague Dinesh Trivedi raised objections to it.

Manmohan sent his national security adviser to Mamata again, he said, explaining his efforts to get Mamata's nod to the deal.

He admitted he may have made a mistake.

“One learns from one's mistake. I'm not claiming that I'm infallible,” said Manmohan who will turn 79 on Sept. 26.

He said he will continue to work with Mamata and will take into account the interests of West Bengal.

That means Mamata and her Paschimbanga have now emerged as a deciding factor in the water sharing deal. The Indian leaders are now indicating that a fresh beginning will be needed in reaching a consensus on the Teesta pact. It is now more important to get Mamata to agree to any deal struck by Dhaka and New Delhi on sharing the Teesta water.

Manmohan is in no mood to upset Mamata, whose Trinamool Congress is a powerful partner in the Congress-led United Democratic Front central government.

Asked if Mamata was responsible for India's diplomatic embarrassment over the Teesta, Manmohan evaded a direct reply, saying, “Mamataji is one of our key political leaders.”

Meanwhile, officials in Dhaka are trying hard to keep their cool despite a general public disappointment over the Teesta failure. A further delay in resolving the Teesta dispute will mean further loss in the multi-million taka Teesta irrigation project.

At a media briefing about the Indian PM's visit, Foreign Secretary Mijarul Quayes said New Delhi is committed to signing the Teesta agreement. “We are hopeful of an agreement within next few months,” he said on Wednesday, echoing the optimism expressed a day earlier by Finance Minister AMA Muhith.

The Teesta debacle prompted Dhaka to pull out from the hoped-for deals on the Feni river, and allowing India to use Chittagong and Mongla ports and transport goods through Bangladesh territory.

In spite of the failures, Manmohan described his maiden bilateral visit to Bangladesh as “very satisfying" and said it would have been more successful had the Teesta agreement been signed.

Meanwhile, Manmohan said he returned from his visit to Bangladesh with the impression that all political parties in that country are willing to work with New Delhi to strengthen bilateral relations.

News Source:  The Daily Star

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Tin Bigha Corridor to remain open for 24 hours from now on

Inhabitants of Bangladeshi enclaves Dahagram and Angorpota on Thursday finally got 24-hour access to the mainland through the Tin Bigha Corridor, two days after India and Bangladesh signed a deal during Prime Minister Manmohan Singh’s visit to Dhaka. The Indian authorities opened the iron gate at 6.30pm for 24 hours, allowing the enclave’s people ‘unfettered movement to their mainland’, ending the decades-old night-time restrictions on their movement. They now ‘feel free and independent’. In a press conference in the Lalmonirhat headquarters of the 31 BGB Battalion, Commanding Officer Lieutenant Colonel Aslam Hossain said that India’s Border Security Force had sent a formal letter to him at 5pm on Thursday, informing him that the Tin Bigha Corridor would be kept opened for 24 hours from 6.30pm today (Thursday). ‘Inhabitants of the Dahagram and Angorpota enclaves will be able to move freely through Tin Bigha Corridor to the mainland. Members of the BGB at Dahagram camp have u...

BNP terms Manmohan’s visit failure; blame government’s bankruptcy

Main opposition BNP has termed as failure the just concluded visit of Indian Prime Minister Manmohan Singh to Bangladesh blaming the government’s “bankruptcy.” Addressing a press conference at the party chairperson’s Gulshan office this (Thursday) morning, BNP acting secretary general Mirza Fakhrul Islam Alamgir said Bangladesh has got nothing mentionable from the Indian Prime Minister’s visit the way the government had focused the visit as historic. He said this has happened due to “diplomatic bankruptcy of the government, lack of coordination, ineptitude, inefficiency and narrowness.” Fakhrul said the scope that was created for resolving the existing problems between the two countries with the visit of the Indian Prime Minister after a decade had resulted into “limitless failure” due to the government’s bankruptcy. The crisis of confidence between the two countries has deepened further with the outcome of the visit, he added. The BNP leader said the government has kept the...

Equitable Teesta deal soon, says Quayes

An equitable deal on the much-hyped sharing of the Teesta River waters will be signed soon between Bangladesh and India, reaffirms the Foreign Secretary. Addressing a press conference at the Foreign Ministry on Thursday afternoon on the outcome of the just-concluded visit of Indian Prime Minister Manmohan Singh to Dhaka, Foreign Secretary Mijarul Quayes said the deal signing will take place within a few months as everything is ready. He said Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina has said the agreement on the Teesta water would be signed within the next three months and her Indian counterpart also assured of it. Replying to a query, he said Bangladesh sought Teesta water sharing on fair and equitable basis as written in the joint statement of the prime ministers of Bangladesh and India. Asked why the deal was not signed during Manmohan’s Dhaka visit, he said, “Because India informed that it’s not possible to sign the agreement now.” He said, “When a country completes its preparations,...